GOVERNOR PROBED Over Massive Federal Fund Abuse

Documents and binder labeled Investigations on desk

Governor Kathy Hochul faces a federal investigation for allegedly hijacking over $1 billion in Medicaid funds meant for vulnerable New Yorkers to instead plug her state’s massive budget shortfall, forcing localities to raise taxes and cut essential services.

Key Takeaways

  • House Republicans, led by Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer and Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, launched an investigation into Governor Hochul for allegedly withholding federal Medicaid funding from counties to address New York’s budget crisis.
  • The alleged scheme has reportedly been ongoing for over 20 years, forcing local governments to increase property taxes and cut services while specifically impacting small and mid-sized counties like Broome and Erie.
  • Nassau University Medical Center sued the state after being denied $1.06 billion in federal Medicaid funding, claiming it had been forced to cover New York’s costs for over two decades.
  • Hochul’s administration responded by orchestrating a “hostile takeover” of the hospital’s board and removing local officials from leadership positions.
  • Congressional investigators have demanded records and communications from Hochul’s office with a July 16 deadline as they probe what they call a “fiscal coverup.”

Billion-Dollar Medicaid Scheme Exposed

House Republicans have launched a sweeping investigation into New York Governor Kathy Hochul over serious allegations that her administration diverted more than $1 billion in federal Medicaid funds intended for vulnerable patients to instead cover the state’s budget shortfall. The investigation, spearheaded by House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer, DOGE Subcommittee Chairwoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, and New York GOP Representatives Mike Lawler and Nick Langworthy, centers on what investigators call a systematic abuse of the federal-state healthcare partnership that has damaged local communities across New York.

“This fiscal coverup has forced local governments to increase property taxes and cut local services,” Republican lawmakers said in their letter to Governor Hochul, demanding documents and communications related to the state’s Medicaid program management.

According to documents from the House Oversight Committee, Hochul’s administration began phasing out federal funding for Medicaid services to localities starting in May 2023, with plans to completely eliminate this support by April 2026. The impact has been particularly severe on smaller counties like Broome and Erie, which have been forced to make difficult financial decisions as the state redirects funds that were meant to support healthcare for low-income residents. These actions appear designed to address New York’s growing budget deficit rather than serve the intended beneficiaries of the program.

Hospital Takeover and Local Government Impact

The investigation has revealed particularly troubling developments in Nassau County, where the funding issues led to what critics describe as a “hostile takeover” of Nassau University Medical Center’s board by the governor. This power grab triggered numerous executive resignations and ultimately removed local officials from leadership positions. The hospital had previously filed a lawsuit against New York State after being denied $1.06 billion in federal Medicaid funding, claiming it had been forced to cover the state’s Federal Medical Assistance Percentage (FMAP) costs for more than two decades.

“As a 10-year veteran of Chautauqua County government, including as county executive, I can tell you that the state saddles county government with the out-of-control cost of Medicaid,” State Sen. George Borello said, highlighting the financial strain placed on local governments by New York’s increasingly bloated Medicaid program.

The congressional investigation has uncovered evidence suggesting that New York State may have been forcing safety net hospitals to reimburse the state’s portion of Medicaid match payments while simultaneously reporting to the federal government that these funds were being properly used by the hospitals. This alleged deception has allowed the state to receive federal matching funds without actually fulfilling its own financial obligations under the Medicaid program—essentially getting federal taxpayers to foot the entire bill while diverting state funds elsewhere.

Congressional Demands and Administration Response

The House Oversight Committee has set a firm July 16 deadline for Governor Hochul to produce all requested records and communications related to the Medicaid funding issue. In their formal request, lawmakers did not mince words about the seriousness of the allegations, stating: “The abuse of federal taxpayer funds intended to ensure health care coverage for the most vulnerable to cover up your state’s budget shortfall is unacceptable,” according to the letter from Rep. Mike Lawler and other congressional investigators.

“The Committee on Oversight and Government Reform (the Committee) is investigating reports that the State of New York has been failing to abide by the law and match federal Medicaid funds. According to recent reports, the State of New York has been withholding or clawing back Medicaid funds from localities and low-income hospitals to buoy its failing balance sheet,” the lawmakers wrote in their official investigation announcement.

Governor Hochul’s administration has attempted to dismiss the investigation as politically motivated. A spokesperson for the governor characterized the probe as merely an attempt by Republicans to distract from their own healthcare policy decisions. However, the bipartisan concern over the alleged misuse of federal funds suggests that this investigation goes beyond typical political theater. With Medicaid serving as a joint state-federal program where federal reimbursement rates range from 50% to 83% based on a state’s income level, the proper administration of these funds represents a significant federal interest that transcends partisan politics.

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR